Oh dear. No one knows how it hurts Haglund to be the bearer of bad news. It’s no fun being the party pooper. The stick in the mud. The sour puss. The wet blanket. The contrarian. He wishes he could stop, but something keeps pushing him. Honesty and love of ballet - not dance - ballet.
The NYCB Gala evening performance on Thursday night was a depressing, self-indulgent collection of formulaic dances that relied little on ballet as an art form. But even as bad as it was, we’re not objecting to loading up any gala with stuff on the level of a high school oral book report for a one-off performance where a shoe-string budget was used. What is reckless, however, is the months-in-advance commitment to loading up the rest of the season with it. When one considers the obscene amount of money that was likely spent to bring these works to the stage, it brings to mind the rich daddy who spent $40K on his 7-year-old’s birthday party just to show everyone that he could do it.
Even though NYCB invited several different designers to contribute their imaginative thinking to the costumes, the end result was like a runway fashion show where all the designers’ artistic voices were distinct but all of the choreography looked like it came out of the same high school text book. True, all of the choreographers came out of SAB. But the evening suggested that none of the choreographers had developed beyond being able to deliver sophomoric drivel — even though we know that’s not necessarily true. Each dance had one or two good ideas, but that was it. Anybody can come up with one or two good ideas for a dance. What ran through each piece was the choreographer’s voice assuring us that what he had to say was terribly important and very deep, but he had no idea how to say it with a ballet vocabulary.
At times in each piece, Haglund wanted to stand up and scream “Just stop already!” Each of these choreographers should continue practicing his/her craft – out of sight under the tutelage of someone who can help them. This country has hundreds of regional, municipal, and civic ballet companies who would just love to have these choreographers come in and hone their craft using local dancers. But it is a travesty when America’s greatest ballet company fills its New York stage with this stuff and proclaims it as the new direction of ballet.
The Wind Still Brings by Troy Schumacher to music by William Walton featured 14 of NYCB’s handsome corps de ballet dancers who freely threw themselves in the air in joyous celebration, ran around the stage, posed, ran around some more, lay down on the floor, did cool So You Think You Can Dance moves, ran around some more. These young dancers were having so much fun. We don’t begrudge them, but we don’t want to pay hefty prices to sit in our seats and watch them, either. In the end, we were asking, “The Wind Still Brings what?” Rain, clouds, snow, or the colloquial IT? Did it even matter?
Gianna Reisen, a recent graduate of SAB and now a dancer with Ballet Semperoper Dresden, used music by Lukas Foss to make her Composer’s Holiday – her first work ever for a professional stage. Foss graduated from The Curtis Institute of Music and then trained in composition under Paul Hindemith during the 1930s. What great choreographer is training Ms. Reisen in composition? Like the others, she’s simply been given expensive, high profile opportunities to figure it all out on her own. Perhaps she was drawn to the Foss composition that featured violin and piano because she is an an admirer of the Stravinsky/Balanchine Duo Concertant. Her intricate pas de deux suggested that might be the case. Gianna used another dozen of NYCB’s handsome corps dancers to create a pensive mood of something or other. She created great photo-op groupings with dancers in arabesque held high in the air. All of it would have looked impressive on Juilliard’s modern dance students.
Lauren Lovette’s Not Our Fate was perhaps the most disappointing of the evening. We were expecting her to pick up where she left off with her first commission For Clara which gave us so much hope about the future of new choreography at NYCB. The Michael Nyman score and this evening's choreography combined to repeatedly echo Christopher Wheeldon’s DGV — and others’ work. How many times have we seen in a NYCB dance a line of dancers run from one side of the stage to another? Too many. It must be really fun to do if so many choreographers want to create new work by using it as a gimmick.
Justin Peck presented an overdose of pas de deux and solos in his Pulcinella Variations. He just kept trotting out couples and soloists to create the most boring academic and cliched responses to Stravinsky’s music. But hey, thank the Lord for Stravinsky’s music this time.
At this gala, the choreography was such a disappointment that we could barely care about the costumes. None of the costumes furthered whatever concepts the choreographies were trying to reveal. As stand-alone designs they ran the gamut from predictable to pretty darned interesting. The predictable included Jonathan Saunders’ bright blue trunks, tunics, and skirts with various stripes for Schumacher’s The Wind Still Brings. There were long strings of fabric hanging off of them like those that hung from the costumes for Schumacher’s Common Ground. There were similarities in the choreography as well.
Virgil Abolh’s dresses for the women in Reisen’s Composer’s Holiday were attractive short dresses with full skirts that moved nicely. The men, in dark pants and mesh long-sleeved tops, were not always easy to see on the dim-lit stage.
Fernando Garcia's and Laura Kims' costume designs for Lauren Lovette’s premiere included black tights and white tee-shirts for the men (innovative, yes?) and yards and yards of flowing fabric - also black and white - draped around the women. Honestly, it didn’t matter.
Tsumori Chisato won the costume contest for for her arty tutu designs worn by Justin Peck’s women dancers. What a missed opportunity it was not to put a stage-full of corps women in the white petaled black-eyed Susan half-tutu that Indiana Woodward wore. It was a truly stunning creation of enormous invention that worked fabulously as she darted around in her fast solo. An eye with red petals around it appeared on other tutus which were full-circle tutus rather than just half. The men’s unitards were colorfully painted and seemed to have climbing vines pictured on them. Like we said, these were the best costumes, but the truth is – the hard, hard truth is that it’s been all downhill for the designers since the Valentino gala several years ago. The Valentino costumes worn by Maria Kowroski and Tiler Peck at that gala are encased in glass by the right side staircase leading up to the promenade. Take moment to look at them. Sheer imaginative beauty.
We were so disappointed in the offerings of the evening that we’re not going to waste a Pump Bump Award. We're tempted to ask ourselves what could be worse than what we saw at the gala; then we remember that ABT is arriving soon. For the first time in over thirty years, Haglund will most likely be skipping an entire ABT season. It seems others will be skipping it to, judging from the pitiful ticket sales; let them give away the house like they do at the Met. There is still plenty of fabulous dancing to take in: Pennsylvania Ballet’s new Sleeping Beauty, the Mariinsky’s La Bayadere at the Kennedy Center, The Red Shoes, Brigadoon.
Just a final word to remind people that an expensive show generally doesn't get to Broadway without first workshopping the nuts and bolts of the production, and massive editing by many people. Turning over thousands upon thousands of dollars to inexperienced or low-experienced or should-know-better-but-don't experienced choreographers to create something stage-worthy in a few weeks is not responsible.